by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

1

DispatchBulletinPolicy

by The Librarian of LCRUA Archives. . 164 reads.

Case ref. 20180727

Date: July 20th, 2018
Party A: South Asians, represented by himself
Party B: Larnion, Yymea and Poulton-with-Fearnhead, represented by Larnion and Poulton-with-Fearnhead
Topic: Conflict between Councillors and President.
Verdicts:

Part I: The contested membership of The Antifascist Union.

Verdict: The Antifascist Union is not a member of the LCRUA, based on the right of every member to be relieved of their membership (I.3). In the context of having changed their mind, the Antifascist Union can reapply for membership without moving back into the region, within a month after getting it revoked.


Part II: The recruitment by Poulton-with-Fearnhead in The LCRUA for Otasija.

Verdict: Poulton-with-Fearnhead was found not guilty. A warning is issued for deceiving Hydra Dragon, which is undignified behaviour (I.4).


Part III: The banning of The Antifascist Union by South Asians.

Verdict: South Asians was found not guilty of revoking The Antifascist Union's membership, as he acted legally. The Tribunal agreed that the action taken by South Asians, and the apparant reasons for taking it (a personal quarrel), did not suit a President.


Part IV: Treason and espionage by Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea.

Verdict: Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea are not guilty of treason or espionage. The Tribunal deemed both treason and espionage irrelevant concepts in a system which allows transparancy upon request and the means to legally overthrow the President.


Part V: South Asians resigned as President, but later reclaimed the position without election.

Verdict: South Asians was legally appointed vice-President by Miravana, but did not fulfill his duty to hold by-elections for the position (IV.4.D).


Part VI: Lack of transparency in the incident by both South Asians and Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea.

Verdict: Both parties are not guilty. Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea's communication on the incident in their group-chat may not be altered and must be preserved with this trial (II.1). (Linkhttps://docs.google.com/document/d/1ykD3Voya6o_UKN_GNh-uVtj7c8L_H7yfdPAcLT9QDkc/edit?usp=sharing)


Part VII: Defamation of South Asians & misinformation by Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea.

Verdict: Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea were found not guilty. Members are allowed to accuse other members if they believe they have a solid basis for the accusations, of which this trial is proof.


Part VIII: Both parties hijacked the founder account. Illegally changing roles, abuse of power and illegal usage of Security Officer powers by Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea.

Verdict: Both parties were found guilty of abusing the Founder account. Larnion, and by association Poulton-with-Fearnhead and Yymea, were found guilty of, without having the legal authority to do so: preventing the closure of an embassy, temporarily renaming an office, and undoing a ban.


Part IX: Council didn't consent with the President closing an embassy.

Verdict: South Asians was found not guilty of closing the embassy without the Council's consent, as it is his legal duty to review the embassies (Embassy Policy). The Tribunal is of the opinion that the Council and President should have communicated better.


Part X: Impeachment of South Asians by Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea.

Verdict: It is legal for any member, including Councillors, to start the process of a referendum to overthrow the President. It would also have been legal for any Councillor to start the by-election for the Presidency which South Asians neglected. It is not legal for the Council to remove the President by a vote amongst itself. The Tribunal believes it was originally intended to be the latter, and found Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead & Yymea guilty.


Punishment:

South Asians shall be removed from power as President. South Asians, Larnion, Poulton-with-Fearnhead and Yymea shall be removed from the Council and may not run in the next Council elections, nor any Council by-elections until then.
Additional: A referendum will be held on Larnion's role as Security Officer.


(Too large for NS)
Linkhttps://discord.gg/XqgGjjf
Look for #tribunal. The various Parts (I trough X) of the case are all pinned to the channel.

Note: The antifascist union has been declared persona non grata (Aug 2nd 2018) by the Council before being able to regain membership, separate from this case. But on Nov 3rd 2018,this status has been removed.

The Librarian of LCRUA Archives

Edited:

RawReport