by Max Barry

Latest Forum Topics

Advertisement

The League of Conservative Nations Board

Search

Search

[+] Advanced...

Author:

Region:

Sort:

«12. . .9,8139,8149,8159,8169,8179,8189,819. . .9,9169,917»

I love the Republic

The Furbish Islands wrote:I love trains

vrooooooooooooooooooooooom

Creeperopolis wrote:first

245379th actually

For the first time in nearly 3 years, the flag has been ever so slightly altered.

Quebecshire wrote:For the first time in nearly 3 years, the flag has been ever so slightly altered.

Are the strips gone?

Quebecshire wrote:Yes

the strips are gone crab rave

Die potato

Noooooooo *splat*

The Legion of Mankind wrote:E

Cringe you should learn the L is the best leter nerd

New Makasta wrote:Cringe you should learn the L is the best leter nerd

W

New Makasta wrote:Cringe you should learn the L is the best leter nerd

PP

Gagium wrote:245379th actually

evidence

First straight person

The Furbish Islands wrote:>US invasion actually resulting in freedom
What kind of strange alternate reality is this

Distinctly untrue. The American Declaration of Independence denounces the Quebec Act. American efforts in Quebec were confused and half-hearted. If Quebec had been conquered by the US, it is likely the Anglo oligarchy of the US would’ve revived the restrictions on Catholicism and Quebecois culture that the Quebec Act abolished.

Salisford wrote:Distinctly untrue. The American Declaration of Independence denounces the Quebec Act. American efforts in Quebec were confused and half-hearted. If Quebec had been conquered by the US, it is likely the Anglo oligarchy of the US would’ve revived the restrictions on Catholicism and Quebecois culture that the Quebec Act abolished.

This is actually probably the major one thing in Quebec history that I'll differ from Willdavie on.

Quebec would not have fared better under American control than British, and I'm highly skeptical that it would've been actually independent. Being one province of Canada is easier to put your foot down than being an American state - I have no problems with the American invasion having failed.

Quebecshire wrote:This is actually probably the major one thing in Quebec history that I'll differ from Willdavie on.

Quebec would not have fared better under American control than British, and I'm highly skeptical that it would've been actually independent. Being one province of Canada is easier to put your foot down than being an American state - I have no problems with the American invasion having failed.

The American invasion didn’t deserve to succeed, either. It was a classic case of overextension when they really should’ve focused on defending American lands. Neither Montgomery nor Arnold were equipped to carry out a siege and coordinate the logistics it would’ve taken to take Quebec from the British. If America couldn’t invade Quebec, there’s no way they could’ve governed it.

Salisford wrote:Distinctly untrue. The American Declaration of Independence denounces the Quebec Act. American efforts in Quebec were confused and half-hearted. If Quebec had been conquered by the US, it is likely the Anglo oligarchy of the US would’ve revived the restrictions on Catholicism and Quebecois culture that the Quebec Act abolished.

I doubt that america would have clamped down on Catholic and quebecois culture in the ways you suggest as America had already adapted significant cultural cleavages into its governing structure by 1776 (like Baltimore) and a French controlled area with the purchase of Louisiana under Jefferson. What is more likely is that American government would’ve been ill-equipped to manage quebec as it was significantly larger and more populated than other territories under their control. American mismanagement would’ve likely doomed the Quebecois to a miserable economy and raised cultural tensions that could’ve resulted in their independence by the 1812.
Again, the prospects of America even succesfully invading quebec (or annexing it) are far-fetched. Even if America had conquered Quebec, they would’ve had to return it in negotiations to the British or hand it over to the French, who would’ve mismanaged it similarly to the Americans and condemned the province to political and economic collapse during the French revolution.

New Makasta wrote:Cringe you should learn the L is the best leter nerd

Trying to understand some people is like trying to smell the color number 9

«12. . .9,8139,8149,8159,8169,8179,8189,819. . .9,9169,917»

Advertisement