The Pacific Board

The Stalwart Federation of The Municipalities of Antarctica

Katrzynija wrote:

Stop stop stop.
What are we actually arguing about??

Bucre not understanding that Germany is much bigger than he originally thought..

Wubdich and Alantic empire

Bucre wrote:

I have bing

That isn't a valid argument. Just because you're using a search engine doesn't mean you're right...

Bunnies, Wubdich, and Alantic empire

Poland lithuanian ruthenia ukraine

Rockemsockem wrote:

im.. going to assume by "how much" you mean cost..
somewhere around 400 million [insert currency]?

Yes I did. And ok, I'll send the money.

Rockemsockem

Post by Bucre suppressed by a moderator.

Wubdich wrote:

What an excellent counter point. Is Bing so drunk to tell you that Ireland and Germany are the same size?

What territory he can claim with a small population

What the heck. Why do you assume that he cant claim Germany with 5 mln people? You do realise that there weren't 80 million people in Germany in let's say 1 AD?

Bunnies and Alantic empire

Katrzynija wrote:

What the heck. Why do you assume that he cant claim Germany with 5 mln people? You do realise that there weren't 80 million people in Germany in let's say 1 AD?

Back then, yes. But my experience on here so far has taught me that claiming territory has to correlate in population. Thus, he would be able to claim a province, but not the entire nation of Germany

The Municipalities of Antarctica and Alantic empire

Post by Bucre suppressed by a moderator.

Wubdich wrote:

Back then, yes. But my experience on here so far has taught me that claiming territory has to correlate in population. Thus, he would be able to claim a province, but not the entire nation of Germany

That is not how you rp. Not to mention that we dont have an official map of earth. Although it would be nice for all nations to be relatively small there is absolutely no reason he shouldnt have Germany. Maybe except of course the fact that the likelihood of him becoming another 3 Reich ripoff increases

Bunnies

The SFSR of Velvets Realm

Bucre wrote:

We are comparing real life to roleplay

In what context is this the best argument for the post you quoted?

Edited

Katrzynija wrote:

Stop stop stop.
What are we actually arguing about??

Some nation is claiming to own a massive country in their universe while not having the population to realistically keep hold of it and thus is being heavily scrutinized for it, or at least that what I got from what I briefly reading through it.

Bunnies and The Municipalities of Antarctica

Katrzynija wrote:

I stand corrected. Partly.

Alantic empire

Post by Bucre suppressed by a moderator.

The Stalwart Federation of The Municipalities of Antarctica

Velvets Realm wrote:

Some nation is claiming to own massive country in their universe while not having the population to realistically keep hold of it and is being scrutinized for it, at least that what I got from what I briefly reading through it.

Yeah but the fact is that populations dont grow 500k a day in the modern world. Do they? Thus I dont really think that NS population metric is really that compatible with roleplay, but since I claim to have a smaller population than stats dictate i have no problems

Bunnies, The Municipalities of Antarctica, and Bucre

Wubdich wrote:

I stand corrected. Partly.

I mean... let me say that as someone who takes the entirely of Antarctica canonically, population does not equal nation size.

Bunnies and Alantic empire

Bucre wrote:

Look at Russia, it's huge but has a small population compared to its size

You're not making sense.

I just asked you how this:

Bucre wrote:

We are comparing real life to roleplay

Is a good response to this:

Wubdich wrote:

What an excellent counter point. Is Bing so drunk to tell you that Ireland and Germany are the same size?

Bunnies and Alantic empire

Alantic empire

Bucre wrote:

Look at Russia, it's huge but has a small population compared to its size

look at Bangladesh

The SFSR of Velvets Realm

Alantic empire wrote:

look at Bangladesh

Caughs in Greenland.

Alantic empire

Post by Bucre suppressed by a moderator.

Katrzynija wrote:

My comment was simply meant to inform you, I wasn't arguing for either side.

The Municipalities of Antarctica and Wubdich

Bucre wrote:

The stats dictate

That still is not a response to their question.

Velvets Realm wrote:

My comment was simply meant to inform you, I wasn't arguing for either side.

Yes.

Wubdich

Bucre wrote:

The stats dictate

Still not what I was asking.

Are Bing results different, especially on an IRL nation's numbers, that your previous claims are valid?

The Municipalities of Antarctica and Alantic empire

Post by Bucre suppressed by a moderator.

Wubdich wrote:

Still not what I was asking.

Are Bing results different, especially on an IRL nation's numbers, that your previous claims are valid?

Now I've started to think a little and the existence of a shared map of nations seems more and more ridiculous. There are inevitably going to be nations that do large time skips or say that each day a month passes. That causes a lot of temporal anomalies. Not to mention that the population stat is going to keep growing the average of 500k people in universe. Also the fact that population stat cannot be decreased in my opinion makes it quite invalid for rp usage

Bunnies, The Municipalities of Antarctica, Wubdich, and Alantic empire

Alantic empire